Why is my electric bill so high in winter with a heat pump?
Why is my electric bill so high in winter with a heat pump?
A high winter electric bill with a heat pump often means auxiliary heating is operating more frequently than expected. Electric resistance backup heat typically consumes considerably more electricity than normal heat pump operation. Cold weather, large thermostat setbacks, restricted airflow, or equipment problems can increase heating demand and cause the backup system to run more often.
Why Does Auxiliary Heat Increase Electricity Costs?
A heat pump normally heats a home by transferring energy from outdoor air into the living space.
Instead of generating all its heat directly through electrical resistance, it moves existing thermal energy using a refrigeration cycle.
This process can deliver more heat energy than the electricity consumed to operate the equipment.
In an all-electric system, auxiliary heating commonly consists of electric resistance heating elements.
These elements convert electricity directly into heat.
Consequently, electric resistance heating generally requires more electricity to deliver the same amount of heat.
Auxiliary heat may activate when:
- Outdoor temperatures reduce available heat pump capacity.
- Indoor temperatures fall substantially below the thermostat setting.
- The thermostat requests a large temperature increase.
- The system enters a defrost cycle and requires supplemental indoor heating.
- Equipment problems prevent the heat pump from meeting normal heating demand.
- Occasional auxiliary heat operation is expected with many systems.
- The concern arises when backup heating becomes the primary source of warmth unnecessarily.
If the thermostat frequently displays AUX during relatively mild weather, professional inspection may be appropriate.
How Does Cold Weather Affect Heat Pump Electricity Consumption?
As outdoor temperatures decline, a heat pump generally must work harder to maintain indoor comfort.
The building also loses heat more rapidly when the temperature difference between indoors and outdoors increases.
For homeowners in Tulsa, Oklahoma, this means electricity consumption can increase significantly during winter cold snaps.
A higher bill during exceptionally cold weather does not automatically indicate a malfunction.
The important question is whether the increase corresponds with weather conditions and reasonable system operation.
Modern cold-climate and variable-speed heat pumps can maintain useful heating capacity at lower temperatures than some older equipment.
A professional can evaluate whether the heat pump is performing within its intended operating range.
Can Thermostat Settings Make a Heat Pump More Expensive to Operate?
Thermostat settings can strongly influence auxiliary heat operation.
A common example involves large overnight temperature setbacks.
Suppose a homeowner lowers the thermostat substantially before bedtime and raises it several degrees the following morning.
For many conventional heat pump systems, moderate and consistent thermostat settings are worth considering.
Homeowners should follow the recommendations for their particular equipment and thermostat.
Other useful practices include:
- Avoiding unnecessarily large temperature adjustments
- Understanding when the AUX indicator appears
- Using compatible thermostat controls
- Keeping supply and return vents unobstructed
- Following the manufacturer’s filter maintenance recommendations
Incorrect settings may cause inefficient operation even when the mechanical equipment is functioning.
What Equipment Problems Can Cause Higher Heating Bills?
Not every increase in winter electricity consumption is caused by normal cold-weather demand.
Outdoor coil problems, including excessive frost accumulation or faulty defrost operation, can reduce performance.
Electrical or control problems may cause auxiliary heating to operate when it is not necessary.
Warning signs include:
- Auxiliary heat running frequently during mild weather
- Unusually long heating cycles
- Difficulty maintaining the thermostat setting
- Persistent ice on the outdoor unit
- Unexplained changes in electricity consumption
- Rooms that remain uncomfortable despite extended heating operation
In Tulsa, Oklahoma, changing winter conditions make it useful to compare energy consumption with recent weather patterns.
A sudden increase that cannot be explained by colder temperatures or greater heating demand deserves investigation.
FAQ
Why is my electric bill so high in winter with a heat pump?
High winter electric bills often result from frequent auxiliary heat operation. When outdoor temperatures fall or the heat pump struggles to maintain comfort, electric resistance backup heat may activate and consume substantially more electricity. Large thermostat setbacks, dirty filters, or equipment problems can increase reliance on backup heat. ProThermal Heating and Cooling can investigate unusual heating costs.
Is it normal for a heat pump to use more electricity in winter?
Yes. Colder outdoor temperatures increase heating demand, and supplemental heating may operate more frequently during demanding conditions.
Does auxiliary heat always mean something is wrong?
No. Auxiliary heat is designed to supplement the heat pump when additional heating is needed. Frequent operation during mild weather may indicate a problem.
Can a dirty filter increase heat pump electricity consumption?
Yes. A clogged filter can restrict airflow, reduce heating performance, and contribute to longer operating cycles or increased supplemental heating.
Should I turn off auxiliary heat to save electricity?
No. Auxiliary heat may be necessary to maintain comfort during colder weather. Have the system evaluated if backup heating appears to operate excessively.
Conclusion
High winter electric bills with a heat pump are often associated with increased heating demand and frequent auxiliary heat operation. Cold weather, thermostat adjustments, airflow restrictions, and equipment problems can all influence electricity consumption.
Customer Reviews
Servant-Hearted Service, Proven Results
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Gary W15 November 2026On time arrival, friendly manner, fullexpaibation of thier findins of the AC and blower system with no pushy "buy this" attitude. The outside units' coils were CAKED in dirt and grass clippings (rent house). Daniel went the extra mile to thoroughly clean all 4 sides, in the heat and sun, without complaint. And without any extra charge! And went into the attic to assess the air ducts/distribution system. All without extra charge (or complaint about the dirt or heat!). And the price for 2 surge protectors (ac and furnace) which I priced with another company, was MUCH more reasonable. Paid for 2 surge protectors, annual ac service maintaince call, 2 airfilters installed and the annual membership renewal for just over 700$. And the other company wanted almost 1,000$ for the same thing. WOW.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Lexi S13 November 2026Blythe came out yesterday & was very thorough & went over everything with us. My husband is a vet & with the Hometown Heroes program we didn’t have to pay anything today. Thank you so much. I will definitely recommend you. Jerry & RobbinTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Cindy T13 November 2026Daniel with ProThermal has done an outstanding job with our heating and cooling units for years. He is very pleasant, thorough, and informative. Outstanding gentleman.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Embeck L13 November 2026Quick and efficient very personable.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Rita M12 November 2026Grant was very progressional and explained everything to me. He showed me pictures so I could see what he was talking about.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Pam F12 November 2026James was very professional and thorough.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Trudy O11 November 2026Grant with Pro Thermal Heating and Cooling is absolutely the best!! His customer service is top notch! I had an issue with my HVAC zone system and he worked diligently until he got it fixed. Thank you Grant for your exceptional service!!Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Gracen R6 November 2026This is my favorite company so far the service is so good especially Amanda she was the best and I just love everythingTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Karen R5 November 2026Very courteous. Polite. Professional. On time. Daniel was awesome. Fixed problem in record time.Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.Posted on Google![]()
Will D5 November 2026ProThermal installed a New Heating and Air Conditioner in my 1960’s home in 2021 “RUNS PERFECT” I always get the $69 TUNE UP YEARLY. Every month I get those flyers from electric co.. “ IM USING LESS ENERGY THEN THE AVE CUSTOMER” Highly recommend!!!!! Bill D Tulsa, OKVerified by TrustindexTrustindex verified badge is the Universal Symbol of Trust. Only the greatest companies can get the verified badge who has a review score above 4.5, based on customer reviews over the past 12 months. Read more